Ryman

Cost of express click and collect: £4.95
Order date and time: 8 May 2017, 9:45am
Promised fulfilment by: Next day (unspecified time)
Item arrived: 8 May, 11:50am (the same day!)
Type of alerts: Email only
Collection point: Main till
Notes: The website was very slow and I didn’t have much hope that this was going to go well for Ryman. However, I received an email just 2 hours after I placed the order letting me know that it was ready for collection. Within that email was a link to use Shutl to pick up my parcel and courier it to me. I thought, 'Cool!' But clicking the link made me realise that the service was not available in my area… a little bit of disappointment that probably could have been avoided by the retailer.
Worth it? Yes.
Worth it for the speed of fulfilment alone.

Topshop

Cost of express click and collect: £3.00
Order date and time: 8 May 2017, 10:14am
Promised fulfilment by: 9 May, 1:00pm
Item arrived: 9 May, 2:58pm (just under 2 hours late)
Type of alerts: Text and email
Collection point: Fitting room
Notes: Topshop’s website is easy to use. The forms felt easy to fill in checkout. The transparency was refreshing – giving an exact time to expect the order. Asking for a mobile number and saying it’s for text updates a nice touch too. However, the item arrived nearly two hours later than originally promised and there were no updates about this delay.
Worth it? No.
If I had been expecting to pick this item up on my lunch break, it would not have been possible. That, coupled with the lack of communication about the late item arrival makes this service not up to par.

River Island

Cost of express click and collect: £5.99
Order date and time: 8 May 2017, 9:54am express click and collect river island
Promised fulfilment by: 10 May, 10:00am
Item arrived: 9 May, 12:26pm (just under 24 hours early)
Type of alerts: Email only
Collection point: Men’s department till (upstairs)
Notes: The River Island website felt very messy for a few reasons. Firstly, many buttons within checkout simply looked out of alignment. Secondly, in the basket a message was displayed saying, 'spend £82 more and get free delivery'. To me, that seems a bit unlikely and may do more harm than upsell. To top it off, River Island was the only retailer within this test where express click and collect was not promised ‘next day’ but said instead, my order would take 2 days. However, my order arrived a day early. In-store the signage for click and collect was non-existent and I had to be verbally directed to the men’s department till upstairs.
Worth it? No.
Even though the item arrived a day early, the originally promised ‘2-day’ delivery is still not 'express' enough for £5.99.

Pets at Home

Cost of express click and collect: £0 with minimum £35 spend
Order date and time: 8 May 2017, 10:04am
Promised fulfilment by: Next day (unspecified time)
Item arrived: 9 May, 2:30pm
Type of alerts: Email and text
Collection point: Main till
Notes: Whilst Pets at Home does not charge for express click and collect, it requires a minimum spend of £35 to qualify. Using the website was fine, not great or bad. Communications were good from the retailer and the package was simple to pick up.
Worth it? Yes.
Being that the service is actually free, of course, it’s worth it. But it is also worth noting that nothing went awry and I would make sure to buy items over £35 to use the service again.

New Look

Cost of express click and collect: £2.99
Order date and time: 8 May 2017, 9:36 am express click and collect new look
Promised fulfilment by: Next day (unspecified time)
Item arrived: 9 May, 10:37am
Type of alerts: Email
Collection point: Main till
Notes: New Looks website is a joy to use. It is easy to browse. The forms are easy to fill. Although it didn’t give me an exact time that my items would be available for collection, it fulfilled the order in the morning, so I would have been able to plan when to pick up easily. The collection point was well marked and the staff were efficient.
Worth it? Yes.
I would give New Look’s express click and collect service a 'best value' badge.

Ampersand ran a Twitter poll recently:

How much would you be willing to pay for Click & Collect, if your item was guaranteed to be ready for pick up by the Next Day?

— Ampersand (@AmpersandHQ) April 10, 2017

Turns out, the results were inconclusive because it really matters to people exactly what time the item will be ready the next day, and a couple of people I chatted with couldn’t put a value on the worth without that information.

At a retailer, it’s difficult to cater for everyone, but by giving as much information as you can, you are allowing your customers to make informed decisions about their purchasing. Isn’t that what multichannel retailing is all about?