Why Being the 'Best' Brand isn’t Good Enough

Article
Tony Lewis

In this excerpt from 2025 Business Book Awards' Marketing cateogry winner "Brand Momentum", learn why being the "best" brand doesn't cut it. The book introduces a radical new way of understanding brand growth – one that predicted the downfall of household names like Monarch Airlines and The Body Shop before their decline became headline news. Read on to find out more.

Many brand owners mistakenly believe that if they can’t be the first, they must be the best and that the best product will win. This notion is rarely true, as there is no such thing as a single, universal ‘best’ product in the customer’s mind – it will be the one that suits each customer best. In most markets, premium and luxury brands tend to have smaller customer bases and smaller opportunities to grow, although their margins mean they can be very profitable.

Unlike ‘maximising’, where we look for the optimal solution (e.g., buying the best), ‘satisficing’, a combination of satisfy and suffice, was introduced by Herbert A. Simon in 1956. It is the idea that people don’t always look for the best but simply something that does the job – a blend of satisfying and sufficing.

Satisficing

Satisficing is the decision-making process that occurs when there isn’t sufficient information to make an informed decision. When we don’t have accurate and meaningful information about which product is best, a brand can be used as a shortcut to help make the choice easier. For this reason, brands can be more successful in categories with fewer rational differences or where emotional decisions prevail.

Let’s face it – we are an inherently lazy species, and our needs and values often focus on simplicity and convenience. We value speed, ease and low effort. We are always looking for better ways to make things easier and quicker, and it’s for this reason that ‘satisficing’ exists. Whilst premium qualities can be crucial to some, especially in luxury markets such as fashion, cars, jewellery, etc, this tends 54 BRAND MOMENTUM: The #1 Growth Metric for Every Boardroom to be the minority in most everyday markets except for the most discerning customers, where availability and buying to a budget are more important. Conveneince stores are a great example of when people choose to satisfice and select brands from very limited ranges.

You don’t actually have to be the first, you just need to be the first in the mind of the customer. This battle for the mind is more important than physically being the first. In other words, you must be the first to take it to the mass market.

A common myth is that Henry Ford invented the automobile. The first car is actually attributed to Karl Benz in 1885/6 with a three-wheeled ‘Motorwagen’3. Henry Ford launched his first car ten years later (1896) but created a new way to mass-produce cars, which helped him gain traction rapidly and so quickly established itself as first in the customer’s mind.

We can’t all be first to market; sometimes, it’s far easier to learn from mistakes and improve on what is out there, and then attempt to steal a slice of the action. This is when it becomes important to differentiate your brand from the market leader or create a new category of your own to dominate. For example, take the yoghurt market, where there are now a dizzying number of categories: Organic, Probiotic Drinking, Greek, Indulgent, Kids, Skyr, Kefir… the list goes on. For each of these, I suspect different brand names will come to mind.

Ultimately, the only thing that matters is how the customer perceives the brand. Brands compete for the mind, which is why brand perceptions and positioning remain essential. Minimising the competition is important to becoming a long-lasting, successful brand. Putting the customer’s mindset at the heart of your business is one of the most fundamental aspects of this book, as Brand Momentum is all about understanding the brand from the customer’s perspective. The only way to find out where your brand stands and what it means is to talk to your target customers, listen to what they have to say, and, most importantly, ask the ‘right’ questions.

Brand Momentum Front Cover

Put Brand Momentum to Work

To find out more, get your copy of Brand Momentum, the groundbreaking book that’s packed with cutting-edge research, innovative strategies, and the psychology behind momentum theory. This is the playbook every marketer and business leader needs in their arsenal to understand how brands truly grow.

To put Brand Momentum to Work in your business, reach out to the experts at Vision One. Our qualitative and quantitative research expertise has helped hundreds of organisations make better decisions and track marketing performance.

Contact Vision One | Get The Book

Want more like this?

Want more like this?

Insight delivered to your inbox

Keep up to date with our free email. Hand picked whitepapers and posts from our blog, as well as exclusive videos and webinar invitations keep our Users one step ahead.

By clicking 'SIGN UP', you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

side image splash

By clicking 'SIGN UP', you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy